Is Surrogacy Legal in New Jersey? A Comprehensive Guide

Surrogacy has become a viable option for many individuals and couples looking to have children. However, the legality of surrogacy varies across the United States, with some states permitting and regulating it while others impose strict bans. If you are considering surrogacy in New Jersey, it is important to understand the state’s legal landscape, requirements, and costs associated with the process.

Legal Status of Surrogacy in New Jersey

Is Surrogacy Legal in New Jersey?

Yes, surrogacy is legal in New Jersey. The state formally legalized and regulated gestational surrogacy in 2018 through the New Jersey Gestational Carrier Agreement Act (NJGCAA), signed by Governor Phil Murphy. This law replaced a previous restrictive legal environment where compensated surrogacy agreements were unenforceable due to a 1988 court ruling in the famous Baby M case.

Under the NJGCAA, gestational surrogacy agreements are legally binding if they meet specific requirements, providing clarity and protection for both intended parents and gestational carriers.

Types of Surrogacy Permitted in New Jersey

There are two types of surrogacy:

• Gestational Surrogacy: The surrogate carries a child that is not genetically related to her. Instead, an embryo is created using the intended parents’ or donors’ sperm and eggs. Legal in New Jersey.
• Traditional Surrogacy: The surrogate is also the biological mother of the child, as her egg is used for conception. Not protected or legally regulated under New Jersey law, making it a legally risky option.

Key Provisions of the New Jersey Gestational Carrier Agreement Act

The NJGCAA outlines strict requirements for surrogacy agreements to be enforceable in court. The law ensures that all parties involved have rights and protections throughout the process. Below are the main provisions:

A. Requirements for Intended Parents

Intended parents must:
✔ Be at least 18 years old
✔ Undergo medical and psychological evaluations
✔ Have a written surrogacy agreement that meets state legal standards

B. Requirements for Gestational Carriers

The gestational carrier (surrogate) must:
✔ Be at least 21 years old
✔ Have previously given birth to at least one child
✔ Undergo medical and psychological screenings
✔ Be financially independent (to ensure they are not coerced into surrogacy for financial reasons)
✔ Have independent legal representation

C. Surrogacy Contract Regulations

A legally binding contract between the intended parents and the surrogate is mandatory. The contract must include:
✔ Compensation details (if it is a compensated surrogacy)
✔ Agreements on medical procedures and decisions
✔ Parental rights establishment before the child’s birth

D. Parental Rights for Intended Parents

New Jersey law allows intended parents to obtain a pre-birth order, meaning that their names can be placed on the birth certificate immediately after the child is born, without requiring adoption procedures.

Costs and Financial Aspects of Surrogacy in New Jersey

Surrogacy is a costly process, involving medical expenses, legal fees, and compensation for the surrogate. Below is a breakdown of typical expenses:

A. Estimated Surrogacy Costs in New Jersey

The total cost of a surrogacy journey in New Jersey ranges between $90,000 and $200,000, depending on various factors such as surrogate compensation, fertility treatments, and legal expenses.

Many intended parents seek financial assistance through loans, grants, or employer-provided fertility benefits. Some insurance policies may cover parts of the medical process, but not surrogate compensation.

---

Ethical and Legal Considerations

A. Ethical Concerns

Surrogacy raises ethical questions, including:

• Exploitation Risks: Critics argue that surrogates, especially those from lower-income backgrounds, may feel financially pressured to participate.
• Parental Rights Issues: If disputes arise between intended parents and surrogates, legal battles can be emotionally and financially exhausting.

B. Legal Risks and Protections

While the NJGCAA provides strong legal protection, surrogacy remains complex and legally sensitive. Hiring an experienced surrogacy attorney is crucial to ensure that all agreements comply with state law.

How New Jersey Compares to Other States

Surrogacy laws vary significantly across the U.S. Here’s how New Jersey compares to other states:

New Jersey is considered one of the most surrogacy-friendly states, along with California, Connecticut, and Illinois.

Steps to Begin a Surrogacy Journey in New Jersey

If you are considering surrogacy in New Jersey, follow these steps:

Step 1: Choose Between Agency vs. Independent Surrogacy

✔ Agencies provide full-service support (matching, legal, medical).
✔ Independent surrogacy is cheaper but requires more effort in finding a surrogate and legal representation.

Step 2: Find a Qualified Surrogate

✔ Work with a licensed surrogacy agency or network privately.
✔ Ensure the surrogate meets NJ legal requirements.

Step 3: Sign a Legal Surrogacy Agreement

✔ Work with an experienced surrogacy attorney to draft the contract.

Step 4: Undergo Medical & Psychological Screening

✔ The surrogate must pass fertility, health, and psychological tests.

Step 5: Begin IVF Process

✔ The embryo is implanted, and pregnancy is monitored by a fertility clinic.

Step 6: Pre-Birth Order & Birth Certificate Process

✔ File for parental rights before birth.

Surrogacy in New Jersey is fully legal and well-regulated, making it a great option for intended parents. The New Jersey Gestational Carrier Agreement Act (NJGCAA) ensures legal clarity and protection for all parties involved. However, surrogacy remains an expensive and complex process, requiring legal and medical expertise.

If you are considering surrogacy in New Jersey, consult with a surrogacy attorney and fertility specialists to navigate the process smoothly.

Would you like help finding specific resources or agencies in New Jersey? Let me know how I can assist you further! 🚀